An agritourism operator can claim agritourism immunity from injury suits only if it complied with the sign-posting requirements of section 570.89, Florida Statutes, and on this record, where the visitor testified no warning signs were present that day, whether the signs were posted is a question for a jury. The Third District Court of Appeal so held on October 28, 2026, in Laguna v. The Berry Farm, LLC, No. 3D2025-1982. It reversed a final summary judgment for the farm. Judge Lobree wrote the opinion. Judges Miller and Gooden completed the panel.
The injury and the agritourism immunity defense
The visitor, called “Collado” in the opinion, went to the farm’s annual Harvest Festival with her three-year-old son — the opinion gives the date as October 10, October 11 and October 21, 2021 in different places, so no single date is settled. She fractured her right ankle when her feet hit the ground after going down a slide in the children’s playground area. She sued for negligence. The farm pleaded immunity under section 570.88(1), which protects an agritourism operator from liability for injury “resulting from the inherent risks of agritourism activities if the notice of risk required under s. 570.89 is posted as required.”
The signs
Section 570.89 requires a sign with a prescribed warning, in black letters at least one inch high, placed “in a clearly visible location at the entrance to the agritourism location and at the site of the agritourism activity.” The farm’s owner swore in an affidavit that compliant signs were posted at the entrance and next to the playground, and attached three photographs of “examples.” The trial court called the affidavit unrebutted, found that the visitor’s inability to recall signs and her Instagram screenshots did not create a genuine dispute, and entered judgment for the farm.
Why the Third District reversed
Because immunity is an affirmative defense, the farm bore the burden of proof at trial, so as movant it had to show the absence of a genuine dispute with credible evidence that would entitle it to a directed verdict. The court said the trial court did not consider the whole of the visitor’s deposition. Although she did not remember any signs outside the entrance, she also testified that warning signs were not present on the day of the incident and that they were “nowhere inside.” The court wrote that “a reasonable jury could conclude that Collado’s testimony was more believable” than the owner’s statement, and that credibility determinations are for the jury.
The photographs did not change that. Two bore a June 2022 date, eight months after the incident, and the location of the third, undated photograph was unclear. The owner also could not say in his deposition when the signs were put up, according to the visitor’s response as the opinion recounts it, although the opinion also recounts his testimony that the signs were placed on the property before the farm’s first opening. The court held that viewing the record in her favor, a triable issue existed on whether the farm complied with section 570.89 that day.
What this does and does not mean
The court reversed on this single basis and remanded for further proceedings. It expressly did not reach the visitor’s alternative argument that her injury did not result from “inherent risks of agritourism activities,” so it did not decide whether a slide injury falls within that term. It also did not decide that the signs were missing; it held only that the record permits a jury to find so. The opinion is internally inconsistent on dates and names: besides the three different incident dates above, it also spells the owner’s surname several ways. The opinion states it is not final until disposition of a timely motion for rehearing.
Related decisions: Can a Passenger Sue Lyft for Safety Misrepresentations After a Driver Assaults Her? The Fourth DCA Says Florida's Rideshare Immunity Statute Bars Those Claims Can you add a punitive damages claim because a driver may have lacked a required license endorsement? Not for a routine rear-end collision, the Third DCA says
Read the opinion (PDF): Download the opinion (PDF)
Source: Laguna v. The Berry Farm, LLC, No. 3D2025-1982 (Fla. 3d DCA Oct. 28, 2026). This article is general information, not legal advice.