Florida's Appellate Courts — Decisions as they issueTuesday, November 17, 2026
Legal news and general information — not legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is created. Read more

Does a Landowner Owe a Duty of Care When It Knows a Tree Is Rotten? Sixth DCA Says Yes on These Allegations

When a rotten tree falls on a neighbor’s house, a Florida landowner who, as alleged, knew the tree was rotten owed adjoining owners a common-law duty to use reasonable care to prevent harm from that tree, and the so-called Massachusetts rule on trees does not remove that duty. The Sixth District Court of Appeal so held on November 6, 2026, in Vaughan v. USMI Properties Five, LLC, No. 6D2025-2288, reversing a judgment on the pleadings for the landowner. Judge Mize wrote the opinion, and Judge Pratt and Associate Judge Beamer concurred.

The rotten tree falls on a neighbor’s house

The two parties own adjacent properties. According to the complaint, a large, rotten oak on USMI’s property fell onto Vaughan’s house in 2022, causing significant damage to his home and home-based business. The complaint alleged that USMI knew for years the tree was rotten and that the tenant living on USMI’s property complained several times about falling limbs. The court stressed that on a motion for judgment on the pleadings, it takes the complaint’s material allegations as true and disregards the answer’s denials.

The trial court’s ruling

USMI argued that Gallo v. Heller (Fla. 3d DCA 1987) and Scott v. McCarty (Fla. 4th DCA 2010) created a categorical rule that a landowner is not liable when a tree on his land causes harm on adjacent property, even if the tree is diseased, the owner knows it, and the harm is foreseeable. The trial court agreed and entered judgment for USMI. Vaughan’s separate negligence per se claim was resolved earlier on summary judgment, and he did not appeal that ruling.

Duty under McCain

Whether a duty exists is a question of law. Under McCain v. Florida Power Corp., “a legal duty will arise whenever a human endeavor creates a generalized and foreseeable risk of harming others.” The court noted that USMI did not dispute that knowingly maintaining a large rotten oak created a foreseeable zone of risk to neighbors, so the complaint adequately alleged a duty.

The Massachusetts rule

The court examined Gallo and Scott and concluded they adopted only the rule that owners are not liable when the limbs, roots or vegetation of healthy trees grow onto a neighbor’s land. Both cases involved healthy trees and articulated the rule that way. The court also described four other tree rules used by other states, the Virginia, Hawaii, Pennsylvania and Restatement rules, and said none would support affirmance on this complaint even if Florida recognized them.

What this does and does not mean

The court was explicit about limits. It did “not decide whether Florida recognizes the Massachusetts rule” or any alternative tree rule, because the issue was not briefed and would require significant historical research. It decided only that the common law of negligence imposed a duty on these allegations and that no exception negates it. It did not decide that USMI breached the duty, that the tree caused the damage, or that Vaughan will recover; those questions go back to the trial court. The opinion also notes that other courts require a plaintiff to show the owner knew or should have known of the tree’s condition. The court warned litigants that it will not follow sister-court decisions without examining whether they are correct. The opinion carries the notice that it is not final until time expires to file a motion for rehearing and any such motion is disposed of.

Related decisions: Does Florida's Agritourism Immunity Protect a Farm Without Proof Its Warning Signs Were Posted? No, the Third DCA Held; a Visitor's Testimony Raised a Jury Question Can a Passenger Sue Lyft for Safety Misrepresentations After a Driver Assaults Her? The Fourth DCA Says Florida's Rideshare Immunity Statute Bars Those Claims

Read the opinion (PDF): Download the opinion (PDF)

Source: Vaughan v. USMI Properties Five, LLC, No. 6D2025-2288 (Fla. 6th DCA Nov. 6, 2026). This article is general information, not legal advice.