The Florida Supreme Court on October 8, 2026, rejected death row inmate William Lee Thompson’s challenges to his death sentence, affirming the summary denial of his successive motion for postconviction relief and denying his petition for a writ of habeas corpus, in Thompson v. State, No. SC2026-1465, consolidated with Thompson v. Secretary, Department of Corrections, No. SC2026-1466. The per curiam opinion rejected Thompson’s claims that he was unconstitutionally denied access to clemency and that Florida’s lethal-injection protocol would violate the Eighth Amendment, and separately denied habeas relief on a decades-old intellectual-disability claim. Justice Tanenbaum concurred with an opinion; Justice Labarga concurred in part and dissented in part.
The 1976 murder
Thompson was sentenced to death for the 1976 murder of Sally Ivester, who was tortured and beaten for hours alongside two other men before dying of internal bleeding. He originally pleaded guilty and was sentenced to death; this Court reversed that judgment in 1977 and allowed him to withdraw the plea, and on remand in 1978 he pleaded guilty again and was resentenced to death. He was resentenced a third time in 1989, after a 1987 postconviction reversal on jury-instruction grounds. His death sentence became final in 1993. He has unsuccessfully litigated his convictions and sentence in state and federal court for decades, including two separate rounds of intellectual-disability litigation.
The warrant, a competency inquiry, and a withdrawal the same day. Governor DeSantis signed Thompson’s death warrant on September 11, 2026, setting execution for October 13, 2026. Six days later, on September 17, 2026, the Governor issued a separate executive order appointing a three-psychiatrist commission under section 922.07, Florida Statutes, to evaluate whether Thompson understands the nature and effect of the death penalty — and “temporarily stayed” the scheduled execution pending that commission’s report. The opinion notes this proceeding is distinct from the claims the Court decided: a footnote states that Thompson’s characterization of his dementia as a new development “bears on his present sanity to be executed — an issue distinct from his intellectual disability claim and not before this Court.” Hours after the Florida Supreme Court denied Thompson’s stay request in this opinion, Governor DeSantis withdrew the death warrant entirely on October 8, 2026 — the first time he has rescinded a death warrant since taking office. Thompson remains on death row without a pending execution date; a new warrant could be signed in the future.
The clemency claim
Thompson argued he was denied due process because he received no clemency proceeding tied specifically to his 1989 death sentence — he had a clemency proceeding in 1982, before his sentence was vacated and reimposed. The Court held clemency in Florida rests in the Governor’s “unfettered discretion,” that due process imposes only minimal procedural safeguards on executive clemency, and that the record showed Governor DeSantis considered and denied clemency before the current warrant issued. Relying on Bundy v. State, the Court held that even accepting Thompson received no clemency proceeding after 1982, that does not establish he was arbitrarily denied access to the clemency process altogether.
The execution-method claim
Thompson argued lethal injection would cause him needless suffering given his medical conditions, and proposed a firing squad as a less-painful alternative. The circuit court rejected the claim on both of the required showings; because Thompson did not challenge the second showing (a viable alternative method) until his reply brief, the Court held that argument was procedurally barred and affirmed without reaching the first.
The habeas petition and the dissent
Thompson’s habeas petition revisited his intellectual-disability claim, arguing the Court should reconsider its 2022 decision that Hall v. Florida does not apply retroactively to his final 1993 sentence. The majority held this was an improper attempt to relitigate a claim through a “manifest injustice” exception that cannot “swallow the rule” against repeat habeas litigation. Justice Labarga dissented from the habeas denial, adhering to his earlier dissent arguing Hall should apply retroactively.
What’s next
The Court ordered that no motion for rehearing will be entertained and that the mandate issue immediately, and found the separate motion for a stay of execution moot given its rulings. With the warrant withdrawn hours later, Thompson’s execution is no longer scheduled, though the State could seek a new death warrant at any time.
Read the opinion (PDF): Download the opinion (PDF)