Florida's Appellate Courts — Decisions as they issueThursday, November 19, 2026
Legal news and general information — not legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is created. Read more

Can Florida Add Probation Fees the Sentencing Judge Never Announced in Court? No, the First DCA Says

A Walton County judge imposed probation fees in a written order that were never said out loud at the sentencing hearing. Florida’s First District Court of Appeal struck them on November 18, 2026, in Barger v. State, No. 1D2023-3210, affirming Sheila Marie Barger’s conviction for leaving the scene of a crash involving death but reversing in part on the sentence. The panel was Judges Roberts, Ray, and Nordby, in a per curiam opinion.

The jury-size argument

Barger first argued she was entitled to a twelve-person jury rather than the six-person jury that convicted her. The court rejected that argument, citing its own 2024 decision in Salmon v. State, which relied on the U.S. Supreme Court’s Williams v. Florida.

The unannounced fees

The written probation order included two special conditions that never came up at sentencing: a requirement that Barger pay the cost of her own drug testing, and a $1 monthly fee to First Step Funds. The court held both should have been struck, citing Parrish v. State and Coupe v. State – a condition that first appears in writing, without being pronounced at the hearing, does not count as part of the sentence.

The lump-sum fine

The judge also pronounced a lump sum of $775 in “court costs” at sentencing. That figure folded in a discretionary $342.86 fine under section 775.083, Florida Statutes, plus a mandatory 5% surcharge. The court held that bundling the discretionary fine into a lump sum, rather than announcing it on its own, was itself an error – citing Whitley v. State – because a defendant needs the chance to contest a discretionary fine specifically. Both the fine and the surcharge tied to it were struck, though the court noted the trial judge may reimpose them later if it gives Barger notice and follows the proper resentencing procedure.

Two clerical errors

The written sentence also mislabeled a $100 fee the judge had actually ordered for the “Local Governmental Trust,” instead citing a statute that does not exist. And the probation order wrongly checked a box saying Barger pleaded no contest, when she was in fact convicted by a jury after pleading not guilty. The court remanded for both to be corrected.

The opinion is not final until disposition of any timely and authorized motion under Florida Rule of Appellate Procedure 9.330 or 9.331.

Also on tagerlaw.com: Can Florida Add Probation Fees the Sentencing Judge Never Announced in Court? No, the First DCA Says