Two defendants convicted by six-person juries argued their constitutional rights were violated because Florida, unlike most states, lets a jury of six decide even serious felony cases. Florida’s Second District Court of Appeal rejected both arguments on November 18, 2026, in Boles v. State, No. 2D2025-1470, and Greenidge v. State, No. 2D2025-1463 – but flagged that the question may not stay settled for long. Judge Silberman wrote both opinions. Judges Northcutt and Labrit concurred in each.
The cases
Diamond Shaquez Boles was convicted by a six-person jury of misdemeanor battery in Pinellas County Court. Jeremy O’Daniel Greenidge was convicted by a six-person jury of sexual battery in Hillsborough Circuit Court. Both argued on appeal that they were entitled to a twelve-person jury instead.
Why the court rejected the argument
The court held that existing precedent does not support either defendant’s position. It pointed to the U.S. Supreme Court’s 1970 decision in Williams v. Florida, which held that a six-member jury does not violate a defendant’s constitutional rights, and to its own recent decision in Bass v. State, which reached the same conclusion. On that authority, the court affirmed both judgments and sentences.
The catch: the U.S. Supreme Court is reconsidering
In both opinions, the court noted that the U.S. Supreme Court has granted certiorari in Kian v. Florida, 146 S. Ct. 2732 (2026), to review a case challenging Williams‘s holding that a six-person jury is constitutional. The Second DCA did not say how it expects that case to come out, and its own rulings here rest entirely on Williams remaining good law. If the Supreme Court reverses course in Kian, Florida’s six-person-jury practice in non-capital cases – and convictions like these – could be open to challenge again.
Both opinions are marked “subject to revision prior to official publication.”
Also on tagerlaw.com: Is Florida's Six-Person Jury Unconstitutional? Not Yet, the Second DCA Says – But the U.S. Supreme Court Just Agreed to Look