Florida's Appellate Courts — Decisions as they issueSaturday, November 21, 2026
Legal news and general information — not legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is created. Read more

Does Swerving Within Your Lane Justify a Florida DUI Stop? Not Without a Safety Concern, the Second DCA Says – But Other Courts Disagree

Swerving within your own lane, and even drifting onto the shoulder several times, does not by itself justify a DUI traffic stop in Florida’s Second District — but the court that just said so also flagged the rule for Supreme Court review. The Second District Court of Appeal affirmed suppression of evidence from a DUI stop on October 30, 2026, in State v. Dunlop, No. 2D2025-1506, and certified its decision to be in direct conflict with rulings from the Sixth and Fifth Districts. Judges Northcutt and Morris concurred; Chief Judge Lucas concurred in the result only, writing separately to argue the court’s own precedent is wrong.

The stop

A Manatee County sheriff’s deputy saw Joshua Dunlop driving his truck around midnight on State Road 64. The deputy watched the truck swerve three to four times within its lane and swerve onto the shoulder three to four more times — once “about half-way into the shoulder.” Unsure whether Dunlop was tired or intoxicated, the deputy initiated a traffic stop, which led to DUI and driver’s-license-restriction charges.

The suppression ruling below

The county court granted Dunlop’s motion to suppress, relying on the Second District’s own 1998 decision in Crooks v. State, and finding Dunlop “was not driving in a rapid, slow, erratic, or aggressive manner” and did not endanger anyone — so his lane movements, standing alone, did not create the reasonable suspicion needed for a stop.

Affirmed, but under protest

The per curiam panel affirmed, citing its own binding precedent that a failure to maintain a single lane under section 316.089(1) is not a violation unless the driving created a reasonable safety concern for the driver or someone else. But Chief Judge Lucas, concurring in the result only, wrote that he believes that precedent misreads the statute. He argued section 316.089(1) actually contains two separate requirements — staying within a lane “as nearly as practicable,” and not changing lanes without first checking it’s safe — and that the safety-concern language only modifies the second requirement, not the first. On that reading, he wrote, a lane-maintenance violation can occur “irrespective of whether anyone is endangered,” aligning with how the Fifth District already reads the same statute in Yanes v. State.

Conflict certified

The panel certified direct conflict with the Sixth District’s Ramos Perez v. State and the Fifth District’s State v. Howard, setting up the question for potential Florida Supreme Court review: does swerving within a lane, without more, ever justify a DUI stop in Florida — or must there be some sign the driving created a reasonable safety concern?

Read the opinion (PDF): Download the opinion (PDF)